In this article we cover:

  • Issues around attic conversion payment
  • Details of the case
  • Questions around certification

A Wicklow builder has been awarded almost €14,000 by Bray District Court following a dispute over payment for renovation works carried out at a family home in Bray, reports the Irish Independent.

Builder Aidan O’Connor brought civil proceedings against homeowners Stephen and Val McCann, claiming he had completed additional works during a renovation and attic conversion project that had not been paid for.

The original renovation contract, valued at €30,000, included a rear extension, rooflights, steel supports, insulation and plastering works.

According to the reporting, the initial phase of the project was paid in full before further attic conversion works were undertaken later in 2024. Mr O’Connor subsequently issued an invoice for €13,981 for the additional work completed.

The homeowners disputed aspects of the work and raised concerns about leaks, insulation and roofing issues, claiming significant remedial works were later required.

Questions were also raised in court about certification, compliance with building regulations and the absence of detailed cost breakdowns.

The claimant said the homeowners had refused to obtain an engineer during the project, and noted that parts of the work had been subcontracted to the builder.

The homeowner claimed he requested the builder’s insurance certificate.

The case highlights several common risks associated with residential renovation projects, including the importance of independent certification during construction as well as the need for detailed written contracts, staged payment schedules, and clearly defined scopes of work.

Judge David Kennedy ultimately ruled in favour of the builder, awarding the full claim amount.